805.934.4600
Part 5: Charitable Remainder and Lead Trusts
Give and Receive: Using Charitable Trusts to Benefit Both Family and Charity
Charitable giving is often framed as a one-way transaction – resources flowing from donor to nonprofit, with the primary benefit accruing to the recipient. But in the world of advanced planning, there are tools that allow donors to give generously while also retaining income, preserving assets for heirs, and achieving long-term financial goals.
Charitable remainder trusts (CRTs) and charitable lead trusts (CLTs) are two such tools. These split-interest trusts offer a unique blend of philanthropy and financial stewardship. They allow donors to support charitable causes while also addressing personal needs such as retirement income, family support, and estate tax mitigation.
In this fifth installment of our series, we’ll explore how CRTs and CLTs work, when they’re appropriate, and how they can be used to create a legacy that benefits both family and charity.
Charitable Remainder Trusts: Income First, Charity Later
A charitable remainder trust is an irrevocable trust that provides income to one or more non-charitable beneficiaries, typically the donor or their family, for a set term or for life. At the end of the trust term, the remaining assets pass to one or more qualified charities.
CRTs come in two primary forms: the charitable remainder annuity trust (CRAT), which pays a fixed dollar amount annually, and the charitable remainder unitrust (CRUT), which pays a fixed percentage of the trust’s value, recalculated annually.
The appeal of a CRT lies in its ability to convert appreciated assets into a stream of income without triggering immediate capital gains tax. For example, a donor might contribute highly appreciated stock or real estate to a CRT. The trust can then sell the asset tax-free and reinvest the proceeds to generate income for the donor.
In return, the donor receives a charitable income tax deduction based on the present value of the remainder interest that will eventually pass to charity. The deduction is calculated using IRS formulas that consider the trust term, payout rate, and applicable interest rates.
CRTs are especially useful for donors who:
- Own appreciated assets they wish to sell without incurring capital gains tax.
- Need income during retirement or for a surviving spouse.
- Want to make a significant charitable gift while retaining financial security.
They are also flexible. A CRT can be structured to last for a fixed number of years (up to 20), for the lifetime of the donor, or for the joint lifetimes of the donor and a spouse. The charitable remainder can be directed to one or more charities, including donor-advised funds or private foundations.
Charitable Lead Trusts: Charity First, Family Later
While CRTs prioritize income to the donor, charitable lead trusts reverse the order. A CLT provides income to a charity for a set term, after which the remaining assets pass to non-charitable beneficiaries, typically the donor’s heirs.
CLTs are often used in estate planning to transfer wealth to the next generation at a reduced tax cost. Because the charity receives income during the trust term, the value of the remainder interest passing to heirs is discounted for gift or estate tax purposes.
There are two main types of CLTs: the charitable lead annuity trust (CLAT), which pays a fixed annual amount to charity, and the charitable lead unitrust (CLUT), which pays a percentage of the trust’s value each year.
CLTs are particularly effective in low-interest rate environments, where the IRS discount rate (known as the Section 7520 rate) allows for greater tax efficiency. The lower the rate, the higher the value of the charitable interest, and the lower the taxable value of the remainder interest.
Donors often use CLTs to:
- Support a favorite charity or foundation for a defined period.
- Transfer appreciating assets to heirs with minimal gift or estate tax.
- Create a structured philanthropic legacy that precedes family inheritance.
Unlike CRTs, CLTs do not provide an income stream to the donor. Instead, they offer a potential gift or estate tax deduction and the satisfaction of supporting charitable work during the trust term.
Choosing the Right Trust
The decision to use a CRT or CLT depends on the donor’s goals. CRTs are best suited for donors who want income now and charitable impact later. CLTs are ideal for those who want to support charity now and transfer wealth to heirs later.
Both trusts require careful planning. They are irrevocable, meaning the terms cannot be changed once the trust is established. They also require legal drafting, ongoing administration, and compliance with IRS rules.
Valuation is critical. The charitable deduction must be supported by actuarial calculations, and the trust must meet specific payout requirements to qualify for tax benefits. For CRTs, the payout must be at least 5% annually. For CLTs, the payout must be sufficient to justify the charitable deduction.
Donors should also consider the type of assets used to fund the trust. Appreciated assets such as stock, real estate, or closely held business interests are often ideal, as they allow for tax-efficient funding and long-term growth.
A Legacy of Balance
Charitable trusts offer a compelling way to balance generosity with financial stewardship. They allow donors to give without giving everything away. They create income, preserve assets, and support causes that matter within a structured, tax-efficient framework.
I’ve worked with clients who used CRTs to fund their retirement while supporting their alma mater. Others have used CLTs to endow scholarships while transferring family wealth to the next generation. In each case, the trust became more than a financial tool, it became a legacy.
These strategies are not for everyone. They require planning, commitment, and professional guidance. But for those with the right assets and the right goals, charitable trusts can be transformative.
Looking Ahead
In our next post, we’ll explore how private foundations can be used to build a family legacy, engage multiple generations, and create a lasting platform for charitable impact. Foundations offer unmatched control and visibility, but they also come with responsibilities. We’ll walk through the pros and cons, and how to decide if a foundation is right for your family.
If you are considering charitable planning, have questions about how to align your giving with your financial goals, or are preparing to sell an asset with significant appreciation, we invite you to schedule a consultation. Strategic charitable planning can reduce and, in some cases, entirely eliminate the tax implications associated with the sale of appreciated assets. Contact us today to explore how these tools can support both your legacy and your financial stewardship.
Next in the Series: Building a Family Legacy Through a Private Foundation