Kirk & Simas -- A Professional Law Corporation
 
     
 
 

 

 Go to Family Law Department home page.

 
 

Dissolution

Children

Property Division

Support

KIRK & SIMAS Home

 
•  PENSION AND RETIREMENT ACCOUNT FAQS  •  

 
Click on any of the Frequently Asked Questions below for a link to the answer.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
•  PENSION AND RETIREMENT ACCOUNT ANSWERS  •  

 
  1.  What is a "Domestic Relations Order?"  A domestic relations order is a judgment, decree or order that is made pursuant to state domestic relations law and that relates to the provisions of child support, alimony, or property rights. (Click here to return to Question #1.)
 
  2.  What is a "Qualified Domestic Relations Order?"  A qualified domestic relations order ("QDRO") is a domestic relations order that creates or recognizes the existence of an alternate payee’s right to receive, or assign to an alternate payee the right to receive, all or a portion of a retirement plan.  (Click here to return to Question #2.)
 
  3.  What is a retirement plan?  There are two types of retirement plans — defined benefit plans and defined contribution plans. A defined benefit plan provides for a specified monthly benefit for life, beginning at retirement and which often is calculated based on years of employment and compensation paid.  A defined contribution plan involves contributions to an account by the employee and/or the employer which are invested in a variety of mutual funds and/or securities. Under a defined contribution plan, the participant gets whatever the account earns.  (Click here to return to Question #3.)
 
  4.  Who is the "Participant" under a QDRO or a DRO?  The Participant is the person who has earned the retirement benefit.  (Click here to return to Question #4.)
 
  5.  Who is the "Alternate Payee" under a QDRO or DRO?  The Alternate Payee is the person that is being awarded a part of the retirement plan as part of the family law proceeding. The Alternate Payee can be a spouse, former spouse, child or other dependent of the Participant.  (Click here to return to Question #5.)
 
  6.  Why is a QDRO so important?   Retirement plans are usually a divorcing couple’s largest asset aside from the family residence. Care should be taken when dealing with such significant assets and should be one of the main focuses when thinking about a property settlement. It is also a source of alimony and child support payments.  (Click here to return to Question #6.)
 
  7.  If there is a Court approved property settlement agreement, is a QDRO necessary?    The property settlement agreement generally does not contain all the details required by the Employee Retirement Income and Security Act of 1974 ("ERISA") and therefore will not be accepted by most plan administrators as a QDRO.  (Click here to return to Question #7.)
 
  8.  Should the parties wait until the Participant spouse retires to prepare the QDRO?  No, a QDRO should be prepared concurrently with or immediately after the Final Judgment of Dissolution is entered. This is especially true of defined contribution accounts where plan administrators require a simple percentage or a dollar amount to divide the account as of the date of separation. However, it is well settled law that the Alternate Payee is entitled to one-half the community interest in the defined contribution account plus interest, earnings and losses from the date of separation to the date of distribution. If a QDRO is prepared immediately after the date entry of judgment the amount of earnings, interest or losses to the date of distribution may be de minimis. If the date of distribution is months or years from the date of separation it will require the help of a forensic economist to determine the impact of the interest, earnings and losses on the Alternate Payee’s community property portion to the date of distribution.  (Click here to return to Question #8.)
 
  9.  Is it possible for the Alternate Payee to lose his/her rights to the retirement benefit?   Yes, if the Participant dies before the QDRO is finished and approved by the plan administrator, the Alternate Payee runs a substantial risk of losing his/her interest in the pension.  (Click here to return to Question #9.)
 
 10.  Is court approval of a QDRO all that is needed for the order to be a QDRO?   No, a domestic relations order is not a QDRO unless the order has been approved by the plan administrator. If rejected by the plan the QDRO must be revised until accepted. A common mistake that attorneys make is to submit a court approved QDRO to the plan administrator without seeking pre-approval. Unless you reserve jurisdiction over subsequent modifications the court does not have jurisdiction to approve subsequent orders.  (Click here to return to Question #10.)
 
 11.  Is a QDRO required to divide all pension plans?   No, the term "QDRO" refers to the type of order required to divide retirement plans that are regulated under ERISA. Most public sector employers provide ERISA type retirement plans. Some States such as California who’s employees are eligible for retirement benefits under the California Public Employees Retirement System ("CALPERS") are regulated under ERISA as well as some counties such as the Santa Barbara County Employee Retirement System ("SBCERS"). Federal and Military retirements are regulated by the United States Code and are referred to as Court Orders Acceptable for Processing ("COAP") and Qualified Military Orders ("QMO") respectively.  (Click here to return to Question #11.)
 
 12.  Should all retirement plans be valued by an expert during a dissolution proceeding?   Generally the answer is "no." Defined benefit plans are generally divided per the time rule also known as the "Shared Interest QDRO" and the alternate payee receives his/her portion of the retirement benefit at the participant’s earliest retirement age. These payments are paid monthly and continue over the lifetime of the participant. However, a defined benefit account should be valued if the participant wishes to buyout the Alternate Payee's interest in the benefit pan at the time of dissolution. (Click here to return to Question #12.)
 
         Defined contribution accounts do not require a valuation unless a significant amount of time has passed between the date of separation and the date of distribution. Often times the plans will not calculate interest, earnings and losses, therefore, you must have an expert perform a valuation to determine the present value of the community interest in the plan.
 
 13.  What authority permits a QDRO?  This mechanism was created by the Retirement Equity Act of 1984 ("REA") as an amendment to the anti-alienation provisions of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 ("ERISA").  (Click here to return to Question #13.)
 
LINKS TO:
                    Go to Family Law Department FAQ List.                               Go to Family Law Department Questionnaires page.             Go to Family Law Department Resources page.                 Go to Family Law Department Attorneys & Staff page.
          Family Law Department FAQ List         Questionnaires          Resource List            Attorneys & Staff
 
Contact KIRK & SIMAS with your family law questions or schedule a consultation today.
                    (Click here to send an e-mail)Send an e-mail to KIRK & SIMAS Family Law Department. or  (Click here to go to our Contact Us page) Go to our Contact Us page.